Russia slams US voting

Russia’s electoral overseer pans “undemocratic” U.S. vote

 File: Russia's electoral overseer dubs U.S. elections "undemocratic."

Getty Images: Marc Serota. File: Russia’s electoral overseer dubs U.S. elections “undemocratic.”
  By Gabriela Baczynska and Timothy Heritage  of Reuters
Possibly in tit-for-tat with U.S. Secretary of State Hilary Clinton, Vladimir Churov, head of Russia’s Central Election Commission, slams U.S. election process.

MOSCOW – Tired of being lectured on democracy, the man known in Russia as “The Magician” for overseeing fraud-marred elections won by Vladimir Putin turned the tables on Wednesday by lambasting the U.S. electoral system.Using language usually reserved for U.S. and European criticism of Russia, Vladimir Churov said American voters will choose a president on Tuesday under an electoral system that is flawed and undemocratic.

Churov, a Putin ally, may still have been smarting over U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s suggestion that Russia’s parliamentary election last December was “neither free nor fair.”

“The U.S. presidential election is not direct, not universal and not equal, and it does not safeguard the secrecy of voting,” Churov, who heads Russia’s Central Election Commission, wrote in the government newspaper Rossiyskaya Gazeta’s online edition.

“The electoral system and electoral laws in the United States are far from perfect. They are contradictory, archaic and do not correspond to the democratic principles the United States has declared as the basis of its foreign and domestic politics.”

He cited a long list of shortcomings such as U.S. methods for registering and identifying voters, vote monitoring which he said was inefficient and mechanisms for casting ballots which he described as questionable.

Washington is unlikely to enjoy being taken to task on democracy by an official from its former Cold War enemy, which also condemned its human rights track-record earlier in October.

The conduct of elections in Russia, which emerged from decades of communist rule in 1991, has regularly been criticized by foreign observers, including the United States.

The irony was also not lost on some Russians. A message sent on a Twitter account pretending to be an official comment by the Russian Foreign Ministry likened Churov’s comments to the head of a Russian car company criticizing U.S. automobiles.


A leading human rights activist described Churov’s five-page article as “state propaganda” intended to deflect attention from Russia’s own democratic failings.

“What is really important is the spirit of the law and of democracy and of elections,” said Grigory Melkonyants, deputy head of Western-funded election monitoring group Golos. “Nobody can question that in regard to the United States. Elections there produce totally legitimate authorities, unlike here.”

Churov, 59, dismissed opposition allegations of widespread fraud in the parliamentary election won by Putin’s United Russia party last December and the presidential election in March.

Opposition leaders started referring to him as “The Magician” when United Russia held on to its parliamentary majority. Churov dismissed the allegations and said Putin’s victory reflected the popular will.

At least some of his views on the U.S. electoral system are shared by others in the political establishment in Russia.

The Foreign Ministry last week said the U.S. State department liked to preach to the rest of the world on democracy and human rights but hinted that it was not always quick to apply these principles on its own soil.

This was a reference to efforts in Texas to ensure international election monitors do not violate a law that bars unauthorized people from entering polling stations.

Russian officials remain sensitive to U.S. criticism and are quick to respond in kind when the opportunity arises, despite attempts by U.S. President Barack Obama – who is in a tight election race against Republican Mitt Romney – to “reset” ties four years ago.

The two veto-wielding U.N. Security Council members still disagree on a number of issues ranging from the conflict in Syria to missile defense.